George Gershwin’s music embodies a timeless American spirit, a vibrant energy that transcends generations. But Who Cares about that today? Balanchine certainly did. In 1970, he choreographed the ballet Who Cares?, a tribute to Gershwin’s enduring legacy. This ballet, set to 16 of Gershwin’s iconic songs composed between 1924 and 1931, isn’t a nostalgic trip down memory lane. Instead, it captures the dynamism of American culture, particularly the exuberant spirit of New York City.
From Hollywood to the Ballet Stage: A Gershwin Collaboration
Gershwin and Balanchine’s partnership began much earlier. In 1937, Gershwin invited Balanchine to Hollywood to collaborate on Goldwyn’s Follies (1938). This film featured a unique Romeo and Juliet sequence, pitting ballet-dancing Montagues against tap-dancing Capulets. Decades later, Who Cares? emerged as a full-fledged testament to their shared artistic vision. So, who cares about a decades-old collaboration? Anyone who appreciates the enduring power of artistic partnerships. This collaboration showcases the timeless appeal of Gershwin’s music and Balanchine’s innovative choreography.
Classic Gershwin: An Eternal Martini
Who Cares? serves as both the title of Balanchine’s ballet and a Gershwin song from the 1931 musical Of Thee I Sing. But who cares about titles? What matters is the enduring quality of the work. Gershwin’s music, much like a classic cocktail, remains eternally refreshing. His compositions, first heard decades ago, retain a piquant freshness, untouched by nostalgia. They evoke a bygone era, yet their vibrancy transcends time when expertly performed. So, who cares if it’s old? Good music is good music.
Beyond Nostalgia: A Celebration of American Style
The Gershwins, George and his lyricist brother Ira, possessed an innate understanding of their audience. They blended sophistication with a touch of playful innocence, creating a unique artistic voice. Who cares about innocence in today’s world? Balanchine, for one. He recognized the enduring power of this unique sensibility. In Who Cares?, he doesn’t merely recreate the past. Instead, he utilizes Gershwin’s melodies as the foundation for classical ballet, showcasing their timeless quality through elegant and dynamic choreography. The result is a celebration of American style, free from sentimentality or cliché.
A Timeless Legacy: Kirstein’s Perspective
Lincoln Kirstein, a prominent figure in American ballet, eloquently captured the essence of Who Cares? He lauded the Gershwins’ ability to blend personal expression with popular appeal. Who cares what a critic thinks? In this case, Kirstein’s insights provide valuable context. He understood that Balanchine’s choreography wasn’t simply a nostalgic revival but a timeless interpretation of Gershwin’s genius. The ballet, with its precise phrasing and emotional resonance, mirrors the brilliance of the music. The result is a masterpiece that continues to resonate with audiences today. Who cares about the past? Those who understand that it shapes the present and inspires the future. Who Cares? is a testament to the enduring power of great art.
